I’ve been drawn to the unexplained long before I began writing Haunted Canada. There’s
something so delicious about a chilly night, a warm blanket, and the goosebumps raised by a good ghost story. I love writing about haunted locations from coast to coast to coast, but as a longtime Durham Region resident, I’m especially drawn to stories from York Durham
Headwaters.
From hotels where you can spend a night with the dead, to restaurants where you might get a side of fright with your foie gras, to museums where the exhibits come to life once the lights are out, YDH is a paradise for paranormal seekers. The ghosts haunting this region aren’t just fodder for spooky tales—they’re windows into our past, rooted in real people and events that helped shape our communities.
Although I write about Canada’s past, I believe history should not just be read, but felt. If you’re curious like me, start with your local haunts. Plan your route, visit historic sites, and join a ghost walk. With a flashlight, an open mind, and a little courage, you can uncover the haunted heart of your own hometown.
– Joel Sutherland author of the famous Canadian classic “Haunted Canada” series
When the air turns crisp and the leaves blaze in hues of orange and gold, York Durham Headwaters (YDH) becomes more than just a picture-perfect fall escape—it transforms into a hotbed of ghostly legends and eerie encounters. From haunted theatres and historic villages to phantom-filled pubs and mysterious roads, this region is a must-visit destination for paranormal seekers, thrill hunters, and anyone who loves a good ghost story. Pack your courage (and maybe a flashlight) and discover why YDH is one of Ontario’s most haunted places.
Dare to Drive These Ghostly Roads
Kirby Road, Vaughan
Perhaps one of the most infamous haunted roads in Ontario, Kirby Road is cloaked in mystery. The legend tells of a girl named Selina, whose gravestone once stood along the road, warning passersby of her untimely death. Drivers and visitors have reported phantom figures, unexplained knocks on car windows, and chilling sounds that seem to follow them down the dark stretch of road. For paranormal adventurers, Kirby Road is a drive you won’t soon forget.
Ghost Road, Port Perry
In Scugog, dare to travel the notorious Ghost Road, where drivers tell of headlights from phantom cars that vanish without a trace. Some say it is the restless spirit of a motorcycle rider who lost his life there, eternally retracing his final ride. Locals insist that if you stop your car, roll down the windows, and listen closely, you may hear the roar of an engine that never reaches you.
Museums and Cultural Sites
The Village at Black Creek, Toronto – Minutes from Vaughan
This historic village is home to some of Ontario’s best-documented hauntings. On ghost walks, visitors have reported chilling encounters in:
- Michael’s Spirit: Footsteps in empty hallways and a swinging chain that only stops when commanded.
- The Manse: Guests knocking three times at the door have heard three knocks back before entering. Doors have also been seen opening on their own.
- Burwick House: Said to be haunted by a grieving mother, where a rocking horse moves by itself and the bed dips as though someone invisible has sat down.
- Fisherville Presbyterian Church: Cold spots and an overwhelming sense of unease greet those who dare to enter.
- The Library: Staff report books falling from shelves and prayer books mysteriously turning pages on their own.
Pickering Museum Village, Pickering
This living history museum may be family-friendly by day, but its 19th-century buildings hold secrets after dark. Paranormal teams and staff have reported footsteps, items moving on their own, disembodied voices, heavy presences watching, and sudden chills. Some men have claimed they felt a push from behind while walking up and down the stairs of one historic home. Visit during one of the museums haunted walks and see if you can feel the spirits watching from the shadows.
Scugog Shores Museum Village, Scugog
Located on Scugog Island near Port Perry, this museum is a collection of heritage buildings where ghost stories abound. Many visitors report strange sounds in the schoolhouse, flickering lights in empty rooms, and feelings of being followed on the grounds at night. This fall visit after dark with the Paranormal Seekers for your very own Ghost Hunt on September 27th. Sign up online.
The Canadian Automotive Museum, Oshawa
Not only does this museum house vintage vehicles, but also restless spirits. Staff and guests claim to have seen shadowy figures darting between cars and heard whispers echoing through the galleries. With dim lighting and the scent of motor oil lingering in the air, it’s the perfect setting for a haunting.
Stephen Leacock Theatre of Performing Arts, Georgina
Theatre-goers and staff have long spoken of ghostly apparitions. Lights flicker without cause, strange footsteps echo backstage, and performers often feel they’re not alone while rehearsing late into the evening.
Newmarket Old Town Hall, Newmarket
A beautiful cultural hub with a spooky past, this historic site is rumored to have lingering spirits from its days as a courthouse and jail. Unexplained noises and cold drafts have added to its haunted reputation.
Theatre Orangeville & Town Hall, Orangeville
Theatre Orangeville’s home in the old Town Hall is another haunted hotspot. Some staff and performers claim to hear applause when the theatre is empty, and phantom figures have been spotted lingering near the stage.
Oshawa Museum, Oshawa
With buildings dating back to the 1800s, the Oshawa Museum is steeped in history and legend. Staff have heard footsteps in deserted halls and seen curtains move when no windows were open. Some even say the spirits of former residents linger, ensuring their stories are never forgotten.
St. George’s Anglican Church and Cemetery, Georgina
This picturesque church is also known for its ghostly tales. Visitors report feeling watched among the headstones and spotting faint figures moving between the graves after dusk.
For More Haunted Sites in Durham Region check out:
Haunted Eats
The Grey Goat Pub, Newmarket
Once the Henry Harrison House, this 1800s building is said to be haunted by a woman who appears in an upstairs window. Patrons and staff have also reported glasses moving on their own and unexplained whispers.
Jester’s Court Pub & Eatery, Port Perry
Housed in an 1800s Victorian building, Jester’s Court is a local haunt in more ways than one. Multiple spirits are said to reside here, including a little girl who tugs at servers’ aprons. Guests have reported cold spots and lights flickering unexpectedly with the biggest hotspot being the women’s bathroom.
Greystones Restaurant & Lounge, Orangeville
This historic stone building, originally Graham’s Tavern, was owned and operated by an Irish-born settler named James Graham in 1879. It is filled with character—and possibly up to 8 different spirits. Diners have claimed to hear footsteps overhead when no one is upstairs, and some staff say they’ve felt unseen hands brush past them.
Haunted Stays
The Briars Resort & Spa, Georgina
This lakeside resort is both luxurious and haunted. Guests have reported ghostly figures wandering the halls, and some have even claimed to see the spirit of a woman gazing out over Lake Simcoe. Despite the hauntings, it’s a relaxing spot to cozy up after a day of ghost hunting.
Millcroft Inn & Spa, Caledon
Known for its rustic charm and serene setting, the Millcroft also carries eerie tales. The ghost of a former worker is said to roam the grounds, and guests sometimes report hearing phantom footsteps on the creaky wooden floors.
The George Stanley Inn, Port Perry
This historic inn is a favorite stop for paranormal enthusiasts. Its creaky floors and candlelit charm are said to host lingering spirits who occasionally make themselves known to overnight guests.
The Nest, Orangeville
This boutique inn is located right above Blue Bird Café & Grill. Restaurant staff have reported noises and ghostly shadows that drift through the restaurant at night, giving an added thrill to your stay.
Plan Your Haunted Adventure
York Durham Headwaters offers more than pumpkin patches and fall foliage—its haunted past makes it a thrilling fall destination. From spooky museums and haunted theatres to pubs where spirits pour more than just drinks, this region is brimming with supernatural stories waiting to be uncovered. Whether you’re a ghost hunter, history buff, or simply love a good scare, YDH promises an unforgettable autumn adventure.
So grab your map, rally your bravest friends, and get ready to discover why York Durham Headwaters might just be Ontario’s most haunted region this fall.
Updated: